X10 Community Forum

🖥️ActiveHome Pro => Plug-ins => Smart Macros => Topic started by: dash on July 10, 2008, 06:59:28 AM

Title: A question about using the same flag (status 'set') in 2 conditions in one macro
Post by: dash on July 10, 2008, 06:59:28 AM

Hi

In a 'lights on' macro I am going to use 'flags 1 and 3 set' as one condition OR 'flags 1 and 2' set as the optional condition.

Will these behave OK? I have a concern that having 'flag 1 set' in both conditions may impact on the function of the macro.

Flag 1 sets upon dusk status on the second unit code of a PIR (this is designed to stop unwanted additional triggers if light level goes up and down from house lamps being operated).

Flag 2 sets in relation to timers on a dummy module such that the flag is set after a certain time on M,T,W,Th

Flag 3 sets in relation to timers on another dummy module such that the flag is set after a different time on F, Sa, Sun

These are there to prevent risk of heavy clouds/low daytime light from triggering the 'lights on' macro and to prevent lights coming on earlier than wanted in winter.

Your comments eagerly awaited !!

  Dave

Title: Re: A question about using the same flag (status 'set') in 2 conditions in one macro
Post by: Walt2 on July 10, 2008, 08:40:44 AM

Quote from: dash on July 10, 2008, 06:59:28 AM

Flag 1 sets upon dusk status on the second unit code of a PIR (this is designed to stop unwanted additional triggers if light level goes up and down from house lamps being operated).

I don't know if you were just being illustrative, but don't use Flags 1, 15, or 16.   >*<

Title: Re: A question about using the same flag (status 'set') in 2 conditions in one macro
Post by: Puck on July 10, 2008, 09:31:45 AM

Quote from: dash on July 10, 2008, 06:59:28 AM

Will these behave OK? I have a concern that having 'flag 1 set' in both conditions may impact on the function of the macro.

There should be no problem with having 'flag 1 set' in both conditions since it is your requirement for the macro to execute. If you have any problems with the OR function, then you can try using an ELSE macro for the 2nd condition.

Quote from: Walt2 on July 10, 2008, 08:40:44 AM

I don't know if you were just being illustrative, but don't use Flags 1, 15, or 16.   >*<

Not all of these flags are a concern any more (at least for all). This is probable due to various CM15A hardware and AHP software revisions. I use flags 1 & 15 on both my CM15As without any problems. I have seen flag 16 toggle on it's own when a macro is being executed, so I still avoid that one.

These flags may be best avoided until you have used up all others, but they can be used and just be aware that their reliability may vary from user to user.

Title: Re: A question about using the same flag (status 'set') in 2 conditions in one macro
Post by: dash on July 10, 2008, 10:16:39 AM

Thanks guys.

I'll give it a try (and will renumber the first flag, just to be on the safe side).


  Dave