🔌General Home Automation > Troubleshooting Automation Problems
Lightning strike and 2 dead WS13As
solareclipse:
Last week we had lightning strike a telephone pole near our house. Best I can tell based on what it damaged and an arc burn from an unconnected coax cable, it travelled in to the house over the cable line. It killed my cable modem, wireless router, a network switch, my VOIP adapter... and 2 of my 3 WS13As. They're the only two dead electronic devices that had no network connection. They also were physically the furthest away from the pole that was hit (although closer to the breaker panel). No breakers tripped, apparently the power didn't even flicker. My CM15A is still working fine, all my other X10 devices are responding normally to RF commands. I'll be able to test my WM100 again tonight when my new router gets delivered.
Any theories on why the WS13As would be the only things affected?
bkenobi:
I'd go with luck.
Brian H:
The WS13A uses both Line and Neutral power connections. If there was a high voltage spike or surge. It may have damaged them.
The X10 modules do have a MOV across the Line to Neutral but they can only absorb so much energy before failing. Many also have a real light gauge fuse wire in them. Maybe they opened up if the WS13A has a fuse wire. The CM15A has a small power transformer in it. It could have been more tolerant of the spikes or surges.
Some times other devices get effected by the surge or spikes. You may find in others slowly failing as more time passes.
Did the incoming cable have a ground block where it entered the house and it was grounded?
solareclipse:
--- Quote from: Brian H on July 08, 2018, 06:27:58 AM ---Did the incoming cable have a ground block where it entered the house and it was grounded?
--- End quote ---
Yes, it was grounded to our water line (well water) although the cable company said they can't do that anymore so they ran a completely new line to the other end of the house where the electric service comes in and grounded to the electric box instead.
Maybe I'll pull apart one of the dead switches and see if I can see anything inside.
Knightrider:
Call me crazy, but ground rods are relatively cheap. I'd prefer a separate ground rod for communications. I hate when they the on to the power ground.
I know you purists will poo poo my statement, but I once had a transient come across a phone line and toast my connection to the rod.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
Go to full version