X10 Community Forum
💬General Category => General Discussion => Topic started by: SkipWX10 on March 24, 2025, 10:25:21 PM
-
Can someone please remind me how to check if the Smartenit servers are down?
Alexa/Smartenit quit and after disabling skill in Alexa, I cannot reenable...Alexa keeps saying 'Unable to link the skill at this time'
Thanks!
-
Server is down since last night. App and Alexa Skill not working. They usually get it back up within a day or two. I've sent emails to the owner and left phone messages this morning.
-
Thanks!
I was worried I'd pooched something...
-
Folks
No one at Smartenit is responding been leaving messages and calling to no avail. I believe the company might have closed.
-
Well this sucks....Smartenit Harmony P2 worked like a dream
Anyone have a suggestion for a different 'plug and play' setup to integrate Alexa and X-10 for us simple minded folks?
-
If the company has closed and our Harmony's become doorstops, there IS an easy & relatively cheap ($35) alternative that I already have working. The Broadlink RM4 Pro at the link below supports X10 RF codes. The RM4 Pro is essentially a learning remote with an Alexa Skill.
The RM4 Pro will learn RF codes from an HR12A which can be triggered by Alexa commands. I use a CM15A as a multi-housecode receiver which sends X10 just like the Harmony.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B096TXWMPV?ref_=ppx_hzsearch_conn_dt_b_fed_asin_title_1
-
Broadlink has released several apps over the years instead of just updating the original app. All still work with my X10 devices and Alexa. The Broadlink web site links to the Magic Home app, an app I’ve not used yet. But it appears it is not new but newly updated. >!
-
I was just searching for this same issue. I had found online that Smartenit was down to 3 employees at some recent time, not a good thing. Their website no longer has any available gateways, just some control hardware so also a sign of death. Thank you both brobin and Tuicemen for the Broadlink solution.
-
It's disappointing that they didn't at least put something on their website or VM message about closing (if they did) and just left everyone wondering.
-
I've reached out to the owner of Smartenit to see if there's an opportunity to take over support of the Harmony server if it makes sense.
QUESTION TO ALL:
If we could take over running the Harmony server (it runs on AWS) how much would you pay per year to subscribe?
I'd be willing to take this on if enough users could make it a break even proposition.
-
Hi Brobin
I would be interested, not sure on the yearly pricing though.
-
I just tested the Magic Home app with my old rm pro sadly it doesn’t work with it but the Broadlink Universal-TV-Remote app still does still does.
-
I've had my Harmony P2 for over 5 years. I worry that it or the PLM module will suffer some sort of electrical failure soon. I was already experiencing lockups about once a month where the Harmony would lose contact with the PLM module, requiring a disconnect / reconnect of the USB cable to correct while both powered. That affected both the app and Alexa skill giving good responses but nothing happening with the PLM. That said, I would not want to invest more than $10 a year, especially if the Broadlink solution solves the Alexa part. I already have the WM100 as a backup for timers and phone app control. Just that the wife likes (and misses) the Alexa part.
Also didn't Smartenit require some type of account to log in?
I've reached out to the owner of Smartenit to see if there's an opportunity to take over support of the Harmony server if it makes sense.
QUESTION TO ALL:
If we could take over running the Harmony server (it runs on AWS) how much would you pay per year to subscribe?
I'd be willing to take this on if enough users could make it a break even proposition.
-
You do need a Smartenit account but, worst case, a new account would be required. The whole thing is a long shot but I figured it wouldn't hurt to see if it's possible. In addition to the Alexa function I've been using the Harmony to send emails/texts as my Stargate can only send email for about an hour after rebooting the WebX. But I can do that with my Yolink hub too so not a big deal.
What's interesting is that, although the Harmony can no longer connect to the server, I'm still getting a daily email from it at Sunset each day as scheduled.
-
UPDATE!!
I just received this reply from the President of Smartenit. They ARE still in business!!
Received today:
The problem has been identified as an inadvertent change of resources in AWS. We are working on a fix and hope to be up by tomorrow at the latest.
Thank you for your patience during this inconvenience.
Al Choperena
President and CEO
-
I received the same message today. Glad the problem was identified and will be resolved by tomorrow.
UPDATE!!
I just received this reply from the President of Smartenit. They ARE still in business!!
Received today:
The problem has been identified as an inadvertent change of resources in AWS. We are working on a fix and hope to be up by tomorrow at the latest.
Thank you for your patience during this inconvenience.
Al Choperena
President and CEO
-
I have several ways to handle Alexa X10 devices. When one fails like the smartenit servers I have a fall back in place. However if the Alexa servers have an issue then I fall back on the phone and one of several apps. As for timers and scenes the broadlink will do these. Still if the internet is down my HomeGenie setup can control things locally.
-
If the company has closed and our Harmony's become doorstops, there IS an easy & relatively cheap ($35) alternative that I already have working. The Broadlink RM4 Pro at the link below supports X10 RF codes. The RM4 Pro is essentially a learning remote with an Alexa Skill.
The RM4 Pro will learn RF codes from an HR12A which can be triggered by Alexa commands. I use a CM15A as a multi-housecode receiver which sends X10 just like the Harmony.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B096TXWMPV?ref_=ppx_hzsearch_conn_dt_b_fed_asin_title_1
Okay, bear with me here...I'm not the brightest with tech...So, if I get the RM4 Pro, I can teach it X-10 addresses with an HR12A, then with the Alexa skill for Broadlink, it will then receive commands from Alexa and transmit RF to my CM15A which will then send the command over the powerline as if I was using the palm pad controller?
Thus, this would be an RF version of the Smartenit sending command to the Insteon PLM via USB and commands going out over the powerline?
Thanks for clarifying for the dummy >!
-
Yes, exactly. Think of as an Alexa enabled Palm Pad or learning remote. In the Broadlink app you learn the X10 codes and name them whatever you want Alexa to control. Set up is quick & easy.
If Smartenit comes back up tomorrow or over the weekend I'll stick with it for now.
-
As of 12:45am Smartenit is back up!