X10 Community Forum

💬General Category => General Discussion => Topic started by: stevem on October 15, 2008, 05:48:33 PM

Title: MS13s (Hawkeye) and alligators
Post by: stevem on October 15, 2008, 05:48:33 PM
An MS13 Hawkeye X10 PIR detects rapidly changing infra-red and if it's aimed suitably then it will be triggered by dogs or cats.  They, like humans, are warm-blooded.

Would it however, detect a decent-sized cold-blooded animal, such an as alligator?

I have a number of MS13s but sadly there aren't a lot of alligators in Europe, so I'm not able to test this out very easily.

Does anybody know?  In the absence of an alligator, I imagine a crocodile, giant tortoise or komodo dragon would suffice, but we don't have very many of those either.

Thanks, Steve
Title: Re: MS13s (Hawkeye) and alligators
Post by: dave w on October 15, 2008, 08:34:51 PM
If you make this a voting question, my vote would be NO.
A cold blooded reptile would be approximately same temperature as the background, so the PIR detector will not see enough differential. 
BTW is this a joke?
Title: Re: MS13s (Hawkeye) and alligators
Post by: HA Dave on October 15, 2008, 09:57:44 PM
An MS13 Hawkeye X10 PIR detects rapidly changing infra-red and if it's aimed suitably then it will be triggered by dogs or cats.  They, like humans, are warm-blooded. Would it however, detect a decent-sized cold-blooded animal, such an as alligator?

We [here at the forum] have many users in southern climates. So does anyone ever get a HawkEye trigger by an alligator? I know here in Ohio.... I've never got one.
Title: Re: MS13s (Hawkeye) and alligators
Post by: stevem on October 16, 2008, 08:08:18 AM
No - it's not a joke; it's a serious although amusing question!

Cheers, Steve
 
Title: Re: MS13s (Hawkeye) and alligators
Post by: Dan Lawrence on October 16, 2008, 07:41:51 PM
Since alligators are cold-blooded, I suspect a MS13 would never see it if standing still.  However, since the MS13 is a motion detector, a moving alligator might show up.
Title: Re: MS13s (Hawkeye) and alligators
Post by: HA Dave on October 17, 2008, 12:07:01 AM
I have always heard that the best way to detect an alligator is to tie (or stake) a barking dog in the area you wish to monitor. When you hear the dog stop barking.... you've detected an alligator.
Title: Re: MS13s (Hawkeye) and alligators
Post by: dave w on October 17, 2008, 07:21:42 PM
I have always heard that the best way to detect an alligator is to tie (or stake) a barking dog in the area you wish to monitor. When you hear the dog stop barking.... you've detected an alligator.
Yes. We used to live in Coral Springs Florida and my ex boss lost a pet dog exactly that way. They lived on a canal, and had a five foot chain link fence around back yard... so thought no gator could get into yard. One night he went out back to find a pretty big gator scaling back over the fence and no more "Fluffy the poodle".

True story.

Maybe I should send him an Eagle Eye for testing?  rofl