X10 Community Forum

💬General Category => General Discussion => Topic started by: Jason B on April 08, 2010, 08:53:41 PM

Title: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: Jason B on April 08, 2010, 08:53:41 PM
I have a porch light that I replaced the incandecent bulbs with a florescent type bulb. Is there something that can control these type bulbs?
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: nybuck on April 08, 2010, 09:06:02 PM
Yes!

The XPS3 - "Ideal for fluorescent lighting"

http://www.activehomepro.com/accessories/pro/xps3_iw_wa1_s.html (http://www.activehomepro.com/accessories/pro/xps3_iw_wa1_s.html)

Although I bought mine for $11 shipped on Ebay   ;D
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: Jason B on April 08, 2010, 09:15:02 PM
Awesome. Do they have for Toggle style switches?
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: Brian H on April 09, 2010, 06:36:45 AM
Just remember. You need a neutral power wire in the switch box for the WS13A to work.

There is no X10 Toggle style non dimming switch.
There maybe other brands with Toggle Style buttons.
I know the Insteon ToggleLinc can have an X10 address added to it but it is like $45.99 ea. It also needs a Neutral wire.
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: nybuck on April 09, 2010, 09:33:46 AM
Here is a link to one on Ebay...  Like Brian said, they are not cheap...

http://cgi.ebay.com/INSTEON-ToggleLinc-V2-Relay-White-2466SW_W0QQitemZ310086350328QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item48329635f8 (http://cgi.ebay.com/INSTEON-ToggleLinc-V2-Relay-White-2466SW_W0QQitemZ310086350328QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item48329635f8)
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: Jason B on April 09, 2010, 10:36:08 AM
Thanks again guys. Is it me, or does anyone find it funny that X10 doesn't have one of these that fits in a toggel wall plate?

Also, what do you mean by neutral wire? What would I look for when I remove the existing switch? I'm a little new at this.
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: nybuck on April 09, 2010, 11:05:47 AM
Standard 120 vac has 3 conductors:  Black, White and green/copper.

Black is the switched power (+)
White is Neutral (-)
Green is ground, also sometimes appears in the wall box as copper, or unjacketed wire.

Often in a switch box, the white is in the back tied directly to the white wire of the light.  The black is in and out of the switch.  One side is hot, the other switches the hot to the light.

I hope that helps!   ;D
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: Brian H on April 09, 2010, 11:16:19 AM
If the White is on one of the switches terminals and it is not a switch that has a indicator light in it. It may NOT be a neutral.
I have switch loops. Where the Black line in the fixture is spliced to the White going to the switch and the Black from the switch ties to the lights line connection. Known as a switch loop and I believe the White in that case should have a black line or piece of tape on it. Though mine do not.
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: Mel99 on April 09, 2010, 11:18:12 AM
Also, what do you mean by neutral wire? What would I look for when I remove the existing switch? I'm a little new at this.

If you don't have a decent Digital Multi Meter, get one before you start working with your wires.  After you're sure the right breaker is off, test every wire in the box before you touch any wire in the box.
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: JeffVolp on April 09, 2010, 12:45:12 PM
After you're sure the right breaker is off, test every wire in the box before you touch any wire in the box.

That is good idea because it is not unusual to have more than one circuit breaker feed a multi-gang box.  And, I have had one circuit breaker (Square D) still feeding power to a circuit when it was switched off.  I had to cycle it ON and OFF again to have it actually disconnect the power.

Jeff
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: Brian H on April 09, 2010, 01:03:35 PM
Gee Jeff. I thought Federal Pacific StabLock Breakers where the only ones that would stick on.
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: dwpatter on April 12, 2010, 03:17:47 AM
Hi;

I also wonder if X10 is going to miss the boat or go out of business because of CFL and LED lightbulbs.

LED bulbs are also a problem, a dimmer module has enough leakage current that the LED stays on at 1/2 brightness when the module is off.

A proper solution is needed, using appliance modules is not a real solution.
They are too expensive and overkill for the application.

New relay modules or smarter solid state modules are required for CFL and LED bulbs.

In some locations incandescent light bulbs are going to be banned.

Then what will we upgrade to, from our current solid state modules ?

X10 offering appliance modules as the CFL solution is very lame.

Dave P.
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: Brian H on April 12, 2010, 06:08:46 AM
Maybe they have something in the future and are moving excessive stock.
Right now you can get eight Lamp; 3 pin appliance; 2 pin appliance modules in the mega module sale for $49.99

I don't think incandescents are going to be banned outright. Manufacturers are working on bulbs that meet the stricter energy saving requirements.
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: dave w on April 12, 2010, 09:21:47 AM
Hi;

I also wonder if X10 is going to miss the boat or go out of business because of CFL and LED lightbulbs.

LED bulbs are also a problem, a dimmer module has enough leakage current that the LED stays on at 1/2 brightness when the module is off.

A proper solution is needed, using appliance modules is not a real solution.
They are too expensive and overkill for the application.

X10 offering appliance modules as the CFL solution is very lame.


FWIW

I doubt X10 is coming with anything new for CFLs or LED bulbs.  Apparently their relay style  "fluorescent" wall switch (WS13), is not suitable for CFLs and LED bulbs otherwise I think X10 would have bimbos advertising such. The problem is a "non-leakage" wall switch would require a neutral line to the switch in addition to the HOT and LOAD lines and most older homes do not have the neutral in "end run" wall switch boxes. Which may be why X10 has not bothered to modify the WS13.

("Brian H Testing Labs"...have you ever checked a WS13 for leakage/sensing currents?)

With proper testing you can use a Socket Rocket for CFLs and LEDs. They turn on fast, shut off completely, and are not dimmable, making them usable for LEDs and CFLs in most cases. X10 states the Socket Rocket is for incandescent bulbs only. This is because the Socket Rocket will add a small amount of distortion to the AC sine wave when ON and X10 is doing a CYB in the event a CFL does not like distortion. Most CFLs and LED bulbs tolerate the distortion with no problem. The test would be to try the Socket Rocket / bulb combination to be sure the bulb does not flicker or run hot. I have SRs driving CFLs, LED bulbs with internal power supplies, and LED ropes with no problems.   
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: Brian H on April 12, 2010, 09:30:17 AM
No I have not checked a WS13A leakage but can. It would be the X10Pro XSP3 in my case.
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: dave w on April 12, 2010, 09:38:14 AM
No I have not checked a WS13A leakage but can. It would be the X10Pro XSP3 in my case.

I'm just wondering if they have "Local Control" leakage for the 3-way application. Or better way to ask...can they control a LED bulb?
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: Brian H on April 12, 2010, 10:39:22 AM
X10Pro XPS3-IW Date Code: 04L51. Not sure what may have changed to 2010.
No local control sensing. I screwed and unscrewed my test light and didn't trip it on from off. It has the low current is the relay on or off sensing.
About 0.29 Ma AC
< 1 Watt three LED C7 night light replacement bulb. Glows
15 LED 1.5 Watt LED bulb. Glows
3 Watt High Intensity LED Bulb universal 120-240 AC input. OK no glow. This bulb is known  to flash on some modules.
13 Watt Honeywell CFL OK. As we know CFLs can vary in sensitivity to the small currents.
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: dave w on April 12, 2010, 10:49:36 AM
HEY THANKS!!   #:)

My guess is the XPS3 and the WS13 are identical, so at least I know my 3 watt Cree LEDs and probably most CFLs should work fine on a WS13. I only have a couple of the "many LEDs in series" bulbs, and was always dispointed in their light output.

Thanks for the information Brian.
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: Brian H on April 24, 2010, 07:05:15 PM
New LED bulbs on the Horizon.

http://seekingalpha.com/article/200446-ge-new-led-light-bulb-looks-like-a-bright-idea?source=email
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: Jason B on April 24, 2010, 08:42:43 PM
Hmm, wonder if the dimmable leds will work with the WS467, or no, because it's under the 25 watt rating?
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: nybuck on April 24, 2010, 10:08:11 PM
New LED bulbs on the Horizon.
http://seekingalpha.com/article/200446-ge-new-led-light-bulb-looks-like-a-bright-idea?source=email

Looks promising, but Yikes   :o - $40-$50 each...  Wonder if the Gov't or the power company will offer a rebate, like when CFL's first came out ???
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: Brian H on April 25, 2010, 06:54:32 AM
The WS467 steals power through the bulb.
So my guess is no they will not work.

Yes $40-$50 is costly, but time may lower the price. I can remember early CFL bulbs also being quite high priced.
My EvoLux S LED bulbs where $79.99 ea. Now I believe they are around $39.99 even though they are the WORSE X10 noise maker I have in my possession and are not dimmable. ???
Title: Re: Can any X10 wall switches control the newer energy saving CFL bulbs?
Post by: amunoztico on May 03, 2010, 05:54:30 PM

Hi everyone.

I installed XPS3 + Fluorescent(CFL) around my house. Most of them work excellent.

However, I have problems with some modules because the CFL usually blink ON.

Can someone post a step-by-step solution? I read other post about to install a 1/2 watt 22k ohm resistor across the load, but I don't understand how to do that. (I'm not a electrician!)

I'd appreciate any help !!!!!!!

Regards!