Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length

Author Topic: Speed for CM15A vs CM11A vs TM751 vs W800RF32A  (Read 5528 times)

marineau

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Helpful Post Rating: 2
  • Posts: 162
Speed for CM15A vs CM11A vs TM751 vs W800RF32A
« on: January 13, 2007, 11:59:46 AM »

I did many tests about a speed for CM15A, CM11A and TM751.
These values are exact .... +/- .033ms

I would like add another values to this list about w800, 1132x or others module that you have.
For this, I needing to use a Video Clip (format mpg or other) that you have to mount with your WebCam, Camcorder or digital Camera.
In this Clip, I must see light LED of the remote control as well as the light which is connected to the LM465

I have a software to define in MilliSecond a time between a led(red) on remote turn on and lamp connected to LM465 turn ON.
If you are intersting to send me a message by MP, and I would give you my Email adress that you can to send me your CLIP.

Each test listed was carried out with command B8-ON to turn ON a module LM465 setted to B8 !

My result are them:

RF Remote:
PalmPad ->TM751 -> LM465 = .866ms (marineau)
PalmPad ->CM15A -> LM465 = .833ms (marineau)
SS13A ->TM751 -> LM465 = .866 (marineau)
SS13A ->CM15A -> LM465 = .833ms (marineau)

PowerLine remote:
MiniController -> LM465 = .666 (marineau) (ON)
MiniController -> LM465 = .233 (marineau) (AllLigthsOn)

Software remote:
ActiveHomePro -> CM15A -> LM465 = .766 (marineau)
MySoftware(SDK)  -> CM15A -> LM465 = .633 (marineau)
ActiveHome -> CM11A -> LM465 = .700 (marineau)
MySoftware(MsComm)  -> CM11A -> LM465 = .900 (marineau)

I will add a result here with your LoginName and send you by MP a exact result !
« Last Edit: November 18, 2007, 03:07:00 PM by marineau »
Logged

marineau

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Helpful Post Rating: 2
  • Posts: 162
Re: Speed for CM15A vs CM11A vs TM751
« Reply #1 on: January 14, 2007, 06:26:52 PM »

New listing:

RF Remote:
PalmPad ->TM751 -> LM465 = .866 (marineau)
PalmPad ->CM15A -> LM465 = .833 (marineau)
SS13A ->TM751 -> LM465 = .866 (marineau)
SS13A ->CM15A -> LM465 = .833 (marineau)

PowerLine remote:
MiniController -> LM465 = .666 (marineau) (ON)
MiniController -> LM465 = .233 (marineau) (AllLigthsOn)

Software remote:
ActiveHomePro -> CM15A -> LM465 = .766 (marineau)
MySoftware(SDK)  -> CM15A -> LM465 = .633 (marineau)
ActiveHome -> CM11A -> LM465 = .700 (marineau)
MySoftware(MsComm)  -> CM11A -> LM465 = .900 (marineau)

Macro by Software or standalone:
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->MySoftware(MsComm) -> CM11A -> LM465(C8-ON) = .933 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->MySoftware(MsComm) -> CM15A -> LM465(C8-ON) = 1.636 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->AHP -> CM15A -> LM465(C8-ON) = 1.900 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A Standalone-> LM465(C8-ON) = .766 (marineau)

If anyone want give me his MPG for others tests, I will to calculate a real result !
« Last Edit: January 14, 2007, 06:53:22 PM by marineau »
Logged

Brian H

  • Community Organizer
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Helpful Post Rating: 305
  • Posts: 13295
Re: Speed for CM15A vs CM11A vs TM751
« Reply #2 on: January 15, 2007, 12:17:30 PM »

Thank you for the time to compile and posting your findings.
This may assist someone with similar questions.
Logged

marineau

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Helpful Post Rating: 2
  • Posts: 162
Re: Speed for CM15A vs CM11A vs TM751
« Reply #3 on: January 18, 2007, 06:37:49 PM »

New listing updated to January 18:

RF Remote:
PalmPad ->TM751 -> LM465 = .866 (marineau)
PalmPad ->CM15A -> LM465 = .833 (marineau)
SS13A ->TM751 -> LM465 = .866 (marineau)
SS13A ->CM15A -> LM465 = .833 (marineau)

PowerLine remote:
MiniController -> LM465 = .666 (marineau) (ON)
MiniController -> LM465 = .233 (marineau) (AllLigthsOn)

Software remote:
ActiveHomePro -> CM15A -> LM465 = .766 (marineau)
MySoftware(SDK)  -> CM15A -> LM465 = .633 (marineau)
ActiveHome -> CM11A -> LM465 = .700 (marineau)
MySoftware(MsComm)  -> CM11A -> LM465 = .900 (marineau)
x10comm.exe-> CM11A -> LM465 = .700 (marineau)
VB Shell to x10comm.exe-> CM11A -> LM465 = .833 (marineau)
Synapse-> 1132B -> LM465 = 1.150 (Brian H)



Macro by Software or standalone:
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->MySoftware(MsComm) -> CM11A -> LM465(C8-ON) = .933 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->MySoftware(MsComm) -> CM15A -> LM465(C8-ON) = 1.636 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->AHP -> CM15A -> LM465(C8-ON) = 1.900 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A Standalone-> LM465(C8-ON) = .766 (marineau)

If anyone want give me his MPG for others tests, I will to calculate a real result !
Logged

marineau

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Helpful Post Rating: 2
  • Posts: 162
Re: Speed for CM15A vs CM11A vs TM751
« Reply #4 on: January 20, 2007, 05:20:15 PM »

New listing updated to January 20:

RF Remote:
PalmPad ->TM751 -> LM465 = .866 (marineau)
PalmPad ->CM15A -> LM465 = .833 (marineau)
SS13A ->TM751 -> LM465 = .866 (marineau)
SS13A ->CM15A -> LM465 = .833 (marineau)

PowerLine remote:
MiniController -> LM465 = .666 (marineau) (ON)
MiniController -> LM465 = .233 (marineau) (AllLigthsOn)

Software remote:
ActiveHomePro -> CM15A -> LM465 = .766 (marineau)
MySoftware(SDK)  -> CM15A -> LM465 = .633 (marineau)
ActiveHome -> CM11A -> LM465 = .700 (marineau)
MySoftware(MsComm)  -> CM11A -> LM465 = .900 (marineau)
x10comm.exe-> CM11A -> LM465 = .700 (marineau)
VB Shell to x10comm.exe-> CM11A -> LM465 = .833 (marineau)
Synapse-> 1132B -> LM465 = 1.150 (Brian H)

Macro by Software or standalone:
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->MySoftware(MsComm) -> CM11A -> LM465(C8-ON) = .933 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->MySoftware(SDK)        -> CM15A -> LM465(C8-ON) = 1.636 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->AHP                            -> CM15A -> LM465(C8-ON) = 1.900 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A Standalone                                    ->  LM465(C8-ON) = .766 (marineau)


Macro by Software or standalone with AllLightsOn or AllLightsOff (NoUnitCode):
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->MySoftware(MsComm) (J-AllLightsON) -> CM11A -> LM465(J16-ON) = .433   (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->MySoftware(SDK)         (J-AllLightsON) -> CM15A -> LM465(J16-ON) = 1.500 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A Standalone                      (J-AllLightsON)                -> LM465(J16-ON) = .566   (marineau)


If anyone want give me his MPG for others tests, I will to calculate a real result !
« Last Edit: January 21, 2007, 09:57:09 AM by marineau »
Logged

marineau

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Helpful Post Rating: 2
  • Posts: 162
Re: Speed for CM15A vs CM11A vs TM751 vs W800RF32A
« Reply #5 on: November 18, 2007, 03:06:25 PM »

Blue = New listing updated to November 18, 2007:

RF Remote:
PalmPad ->TM751 -> LM465 = .866 (marineau)
PalmPad ->CM15A -> LM465 = .833 (marineau)
SS13A ->TM751 -> LM465 = .866 (marineau)
SS13A ->CM15A -> LM465 = .833 (marineau)


PowerLine remote:
MiniController -> LM465 = .666 (marineau) (ON)
MiniController -> LM465 = .233 (marineau) (AllLigthsOn)

Software remote:
ActiveHomePro -> CM15A -> LM465 = .766 (marineau)
MySoftware(SDK)  -> CM15A -> LM465 = .633 (marineau)
ActiveHome -> CM11A -> LM465 = .700 (marineau)
MySoftware(MsComm)  -> CM11A -> LM465 = .900 (marineau)
x10comm.exe-> CM11A -> LM465 = .700 (marineau)
VB Shell to x10comm.exe-> CM11A -> LM465 = .833 (marineau)
Synapse-> 1132B -> LM465 = 1.150 (Brian H)

Macro by Software or standalone:
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->MySoftware(MsComm) -> CM11A -> LM465(C8-ON) = .933 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->MySoftware(SDK)        -> CM15A -> LM465(C8-ON) = 1.636 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->AHP                            -> CM15A -> LM465(C8-ON) = 1.900 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A Standalone                                    ->  LM465(C8-ON) = .766 (marineau)

Macro by Software or standalone with AllLightsOn or AllLightsOff (NoUnitCode):
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->MySoftware(MsComm) (J-AllLightsON) -> CM11A -> LM465(J16-ON) = .433   (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A ->MySoftware(SDK)         (J-AllLightsON) -> CM15A -> LM465(J16-ON) = 1.500 (marineau)
PalmPad(B8-ON) ->CM15A Standalone                      (J-AllLightsON)                -> LM465(J16-ON) = .566   (marineau)

Time needed to RF_receiver to receive and send command to Software :
SS13A(M2-ON) -> W800RF32A -> MySoftware(MsComm) = .166 (marineau)
SS13A(M2-ON) -> CM15A         ->MySoftware(SDK) = .244 (marineau) 
SS13A(M2-ON) -> W800RF32A -> MySoftware(MsComm) (J-AllLightsON)  -> CM15A= .891 (marineau)


So W800RF32A is faster than CM15A to receive RF signal !

If anyone want send me his MPG for others hardware, I can calculate a real result !
« Last Edit: November 18, 2007, 05:21:40 PM by marineau »
Logged
 

X10.com | About X10 | X10 Security Systems | Cameras| Package Deals
© Copyright 2014-2016 X10.com All rights reserved.