Hey Dave, been a while.
None of those approaches are really what I want though. I want something very simple and compact. Ideally, just a single on/off button that would allow me to turn all lights on an off from my bed.
I have tried BVC and that setup was too unreliable for me, overly complex, and ultimately I found that I do not care to speak out loud to do actions. I really don't want a full size remote or anything like that hanging from the wall.
The closest thing I have now is a keychain remote stuck to the wall. It works pretty good, but can sometimes be hard to locate by feel since it has no illumination.
I guess I am thinking more like something with an indiglo or glow in the dark, or a light on it.
Also, I did try a motion sensor setup and could never get it to properly understand all scenarios. Sometimes it worked fine, while under certain circumstances it was annoying. Plus, when you add in the factor of another person in your bed, it gets really messed up.
As far as the iphone goes, the controller needs to be hooked to the computer, which I really don't want to do. I prefer it to be standalone. Also, it is not very practical to unlock your iphone just to turn a light on or off. I would much rather just hunt for the wall controller in the dark by feel than hunt for my iphone (and maybe drop it), then unlock it, launch the app...etc. Totally defeats the purpose of automation.
It should be simple, simple, simple little button that can be easily pressed at night with low light.