Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[nklght]

I would like X-10 to show a comparable table or chart of specifications of comparable items.  I am trying to figure out what the difference is between the different motion sensors.  From what I learned from the X-10 website, they all do the same thing but have different costs.  I know that certain motion sensors from alarm companies will not trigger if an item is under 80 pounds do any X-10 sensors operate the same.  Besides the X-10 Pro modules which provide 2-way comunication, their are several modules provided by X-10 which do the same thing and vary in price.  When shopping for a module, I am looking for an item that does what I need it to do, When two modules perform in the same manner and have different prices with no explanation to the difference, I will purchase the cheaper.  I have noticed that some of the more costly units include a 2 year warranty instead of the standard 1 year.  Just provide me with a chart so I can determine which Item will do what I need it to do.

[steven r]

I would like X-10 to show a comparable table or chart of specifications of comparable items....

This is a great idea!
I'd like to see one for the cameras.
It's hard enough trying to scroll through all the different areas of the web site. A chart or even better the ability the select a few items for comparison would be helpful.

[nklght]

Steven,
It is tough to decipher the X-10 website.  They offer multiple items which will perform the same duty, yet no real difference is listed.

[steven r]

...It is tough to decipher the X-10 website.  They offer multiple items which will perform the same duty, yet no real difference is listed.

My point exactly.
Fortunately they have at least one new web designer (joined X10 in Jan) that seems to have a more practical and less flashy approach to site design. See this site.

[Brian H]

I have seen a comparison chart of X10 Motion Sensors. Only problem is it may have been on a third party automation related web site. There are differences between the sensors. Like adjustbale time of no motion before the off is sent and weather resistant or not.

[steven r]

...There are differences between the sensors....

...and knowing these product differences before buying them leads to happier campers. 
eg. I haven't bought a camera for my front porch in part because I'm not sure what flashy ad better meets my need.

[Dan Lawrence]

As I long time X10 user (from the DOS days), I also want to better product specs for X10's entire line. Much of my X-10 expertise has been OJT training. Buy it and install it, then use it and if someting goes awry, you either get help from another user or, if you're lucky, an X-10 dealer is near you can can help.

[nklght]

Dan,
I have also used X-10 for quite some time, it did some amazing stuff without the need of an computer.  Now AHP needs to run on an computer, and is still only availble to run options which were available wiithout an computer.  Lead it to RadioShack to ruin a great thing remember Cue Cat.

[steven r]

...Lead it to RadioShack to ruin a great thing remember Cue Cat.

I had forgotton about Cue Cat. Is that piece of hardware / software still in use?

[JimC]

had forgotton about Cue Cat. Is that piece of hardware / software still in use?

Last time I tried to use mine, which was a year ago I was directed to a site that stated they were no longer in business.

[steven r]

had forgotton about Cue Cat. Is that piece of hardware / software still in use?

Last time I tried to use mine, which was a year ago I was directed to a site that stated they were no longer in business.

For anyone that misses CueCat^TM, try this UPC data base.
If you still have your CueCat^TM scanner you can use it (Make sure you've uninstalled the CueCat^TM software.) otherwise you'll have to type in the UPC. This guy keeps the data base as a hobby.
Hmm... Now where did I toss that CueCat^TM?

[amigamax]

Here's your motion sensor comparison:

This page tells the differeence between ActiveEye, HawkEye, EagleEye, and Pro sensors.
Good page if they ever put equal effort into support they have put into advertising. 

http://www.activehomepro.com/sensors_compare.htm

Gimme a kudo "it was useful" if it tells you what you want to know!

I know I'll reference it!

Hawk & Pro are white; Eagle & Active are not.

Gizmo

[-Bill- (of wgjohns.com)]

For anyone that misses CueCat^TM, try this UPC data base.
If you still have your CueCat^TM scanner you can use it (Make sure you've uninstalled the CueCat^TM software.) otherwise you'll have to type in the UPC. This guy keeps the data base as a hobby.
Hmm... Now where did I toss that CueCat^TM?

In my case, it's in the spare bedroom closet, probably very near the (still working) Timex Sinclair 1000 computer!

I suddenly feel very old. 

[dave w]

Bill,

I have an Atari 800, a Commodore 64, and brown modules that say "BSR System X10" so you ain't the only one feelin old ;-)

[-Bill- (of wgjohns.com)]

Bill,

I have an Atari 800, a Commodore 64, and brown modules that say "BSR System X10" so you ain't the only one feelin old ;-)

I miss my Atari 800 and the 1200XL (I really wanted the 1450XLD!)  I still have a service manual (2 inch thick tome!) with the schematics for the 800 and the source-code for the ROMs!  I'm sure it will come in handy some day 

The Commodore Vic 20 might even still work, but the C64 has a bad video chip.  My wife made me give away all the Apple II, IIe and Apple III stuff. 

Sorry all, I think this went a bit off-topic.